Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Homi Hormasji's avatar

Yes, we made this happen. I hang my head in shame.

David, switching gears (to some slight extent), one of the problems with our unwieldy system of government is that there isn't any formal opposition as such to counter the deluge of lies and falsehoods which Trump has been unleashing, and will continue to do, in his attempt to conflate reality with propaganda. Yes, there are prominent individuals, in and out of government, whom the media will seek out for their opinions on any particular lie that the orange blob utters, but all that this effectively does is to keep viewership numbers up so that the news outlets can pursue their main existential function of generating advertising revenue. In practical terms, however, there is no "official" body that could regularly be consulted in order to provide a factual consensus of opinion.

In the normal course of events, there would be no such formal body to state the opposition case until the Democrats hold primaries to select a candidate prior to the next presidential election (if it were ever to take place).

Well, Professor Timothy Snyder offered a wonderful suggestion in a recent Substack post, namely, that the Democratic Party - in reflecting what is parliamentary practice in Britain - should form a shadow cabinet to counter all the MAGA lies and to provide a balanced and truthful perspective on a continual basis: https://open.substack.com/pub/snyder/p/shadow-cabinet?r=dkq3&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=email.

I believe that this is something that we should all get behind and demand of our Democratic leaders. The shadow cabinet could comprise of people, both, in and out of Congress, but each member should be an expert in his or her field. For example, the shadow cabinet could have Professor Robert Reich as the shadow secretary of labor, and David Rothkopf as the shadow foreign secretary.

What say you?

Expand full comment
SandraLea's avatar

And there it is….Ka-ching.

Expand full comment
44 more comments...

No posts